Questions · Straight Answers

Were the Gnostics Christians? Gnosticism vs. Christianity

Most of them were, by their own account. The people behind the Gospel of Philip, the Gospel of Truth and the Secret Book of John called themselves Christians, were baptized, and read Paul and John; Valentinus, the best known of their teachers, was by one hostile account nearly made bishop of Rome. What set them apart was the creator: most gnostic texts say this world was made by a lesser, ignorant power, and that Jesus came from the true God above it to awaken people, who are saved by knowing where they came from. The bishops who wrote against them called them heretics, Christians who had gone wrong, not outsiders. A few texts now grouped as 'gnostic', like the Hermetic Poimandres, have no Christ in them at all.

From the text: The Gospel of Philip. Read it complete and free.

The short answer

Yes, for the most part, and they would have been surprised by the question. The teachers and writers we now call gnostics, in the second and third centuries, put Jesus at the center of what they taught, practiced baptism, and read the letters of Paul and the Gospel of John as closely as anyone. Their opponents called them heretics, which is a charge against Christians, not against outsiders. The fight between them was a fight inside the Christian movement over who had understood Jesus.

“Gnostic” itself was mostly a label applied from outside. A few groups used it of themselves, and Clement of Alexandria, a mainstream teacher, called the mature Christian the “true gnostic”. Modern scholars such as Michael Williams and Karen King have argued that the category lumps together groups that had little in common. That is worth keeping in mind: there was no single gnostic church to compare with the Christian one.

What they said about themselves

The Gospel of Philip, a collection of teachings from Nag Hammadi Codex II, uses the word “Christian” of its own readers. In Mark M. Mattison's translation:

“When we were Hebrews, we were fatherless: we had (only) our mother. But when we became Christians, we gained both father and mother.”

And it is strict about who deserves the name. Baptism alone does not make you one:

“If someone goes down into the water and comes up without having received anything, and says, "I'm a Christian," they've borrowed the name at interest. But if they receive the Holy Spirit, they have the gift of the name.”

This is not someone leaving Christianity. It is someone arguing that most Christians have not gone far enough, that past baptism there are further rites, the chrism and the bridal chamber, after which a person “is no longer a [Christian], but a Christ.” The claim is to be the inner circle of the church, not its rival.

Where they parted from the church

The main difference is the creator. The Secret Book of John and the texts like it say that the world was made by a lesser power, often called Yaldabaoth, who did not know the true God above him and claimed to be the only one. Jesus comes from that higher God to remind people of where they came from, and what saves is that knowledge, gnosis, more than faith in his death. The church taught one good God who made the world, and a Christ who saves through the cross and the resurrection of the body.

From that one difference follow the others: how to read Genesis, whether the resurrection is of the body, who among the disciples understood Jesus best (often Mary Magdalene, in the gnostic texts), and whether some believers have received more than others. The side-by-side table is in gnostic gospels vs. the Bible, and the beliefs in brief are in what gnostics believe.

What one gospel says about the church

Some gnostic texts are openly critical of the mainstream churches. The Gospel of Judas opens with Jesus finding the disciples praying over bread, in Mattison's translation:

“When he [came up to] his disciples sitting together praying over the bread, [he] laughed. The disciples said to him, "Master, why are you laughing at [our] prayer? What have we done? [This] is what's right." He answered and said to them, "I'm not laughing at you. You're not doing this because you want to, but because through this your God [will be] praised."”

“Your God”, not his: the twelve are praying to the lesser creator without knowing it. Later in the same gospel they dream of priests at an altar who invoke Jesus' name while doing wrong, and Jesus tells them the priests are themselves. It is a Christian text attacking other Christians, which is exactly what the mainstream writers were doing in return.

What the church said about them

Around 180 CE Irenaeus, bishop of Lyons, wrote five books Against Heresies, most of them about the gnostic teachers. He complains that they speak like the church and read the same scriptures, which is why he thought them dangerous. Tertullian reports that Valentinus expected to be made bishop of Rome and left only when another man was chosen. The Valentinians went on attending church while meeting in their own circles for further teaching. Until the Nag Hammadi find in 1945, these opponents were nearly all we had: the thirteen codices let the other side speak for the first time in sixteen centuries.

Gnostic texts with no Christ in them

Not everything filed under “gnostic” is Christian. The Hermetic Poimandres tells a creation story and a path of ascent with no Jesus in it at all. Several Nag Hammadi treatises in the Sethian tradition are the same, and the Mandaeans, the one gnostic religion that survives today, honor John the Baptist and reject Jesus. So the best answer is that most gnostics were Christians, some were not, and the word covers a family of movements rather than one church.

Reading them for yourself

For centuries the gnostics were known only through their critics. Now their own books can be read whole, and every text quoted here is in this library, free, with its manuscript and translator named: Philip, Judas, the Gospel of Truth and the Secret Book of John. Whatever you conclude about their teaching, they are some of the oldest Christian writings outside the New Testament.

Common questions

Were the gnostics Christians?

Most of them, by their own account. The authors of the Gospel of Philip, the Gospel of Truth and the Secret Book of John put Jesus at the center, practiced baptism and read Paul and John. The bishops who wrote against them called them heretics, not pagans. A few texts now filed under 'gnostic', such as the Hermetic Poimandres, have no Christ in them at all.

What is the difference between Gnosticism and Christianity?

The main one is the creator. Most gnostic texts say the world was made by a lesser power, not by the highest God, and that Jesus came from that highest God to wake people up. Salvation comes through knowledge (gnosis) of where you came from, more than through faith in the cross. The church taught one good God who made the world, and a Christ who saves by his death and resurrection.

Is Gnosticism a heresy?

To the churches that became mainstream, yes: Irenaeus of Lyons wrote five books against the gnostic teachers around 180 CE, and the label stuck. In the second century 'heresy' (Greek hairesis) still meant a school or a choice, and the boundary between the churches and the gnostic groups was argued over for generations before it was settled.

Did Jesus teach Gnosticism?

There is no evidence that he taught the developed gnostic myth of a false creator and the aeons. The gnostic gospels were written in the second century and later, a generation or more after the New Testament gospels, though some sayings in the Gospel of Thomas may be as old as the sayings behind Matthew and Luke.

Can Christians read the gnostic gospels?

Anyone can read them as history: they are among the oldest Christian writings outside the New Testament and show how varied the first Christian centuries were. Reading them does not commit you to their teaching, any more than reading Irenaeus commits you to his. This library gives each text whole, with its manuscript and translator named.