Questions · Straight Answers

Hermeticism vs Gnosticism: What Is the Difference?

Hermeticism and Gnosticism are separate movements from the same world, Roman Egypt in the first centuries CE. Both teach that knowing God frees the soul. Hermetic texts such as the Poimandres speak in the name of Hermes, are not Christian, and tend to see the cosmos as the work of a good God. Many Gnostic texts see it as the flawed work of a lesser one.

Read the Hermetic vision itself: Poimandres. Read it complete and free.

Two movements, one time and place

The Hermetic writings are Greek treatises composed in Egypt under Roman rule, in the name of Hermes Trismegistus, “Thrice-Greatest Hermes”, a figure who joins the Greek god Hermes to the Egyptian god Thoth. Seventeen of them were later gathered as the Corpus Hermeticum. Brian Copenhaver, in the introduction to his translation Hermetica (1992), dates them between about 100 and 300 CE.

Gnosticism is a modern name for a family of religious groups of the second to fourth centuries, most of them Christian, who taught that a hidden knowledge (in Greek, gnosis) saves. Their books include the Secret Book of John, whose story a bishop was already arguing against around the year 180.

So the two grew up together, in the same cities, in the same language, reading the same philosophers. That is why they sound alike, and why the differences are worth setting out with care.

The Poimandres in brief

The Poimandres is the first treatise of the Corpus Hermeticum and the best place to hear the Hermetic voice. A seeker, his senses stilled, is met by an immense being. The quotations here are from G. R. S. Mead's public-domain translation of 1906:

He saith: I am Man-Shepherd, Mind of all-masterhood; I know what thou desirest and I’m with thee everywhere.

Poimandres, section 2

Poimandres shows him how the world came to be: light, then a darkness, then a Word that brings order. God, the Mind, brings forth a second Mind who shapes the cosmos, and then a Human in his own image. The Human looks down through the spheres, sees his reflection in Nature, loves it, and comes to live in it. That is the Hermetic account of why people are as they are:

And this is why beyond all creatures on the earth man is twofold; mortal because of body, but because of the essential Man immortal.

Poimandres, section 15

The way back is to know this about oneself. At death the soul climbs through seven zones, giving back to each the fault it took on there, and arrives stripped and whole:

This the good end for those who have gained Gnosis, to be made one with God.

Poimandres, section 26

What they share

A reader who comes to the Poimandres from the Gnostic gospels will recognise the outline at once.

  • Knowledge saves. The word in the last quotation is the same Greek word, gnosis. In both traditions a person is rescued by learning what they are and where they come from.
  • The human being is divine in origin. Something in us belongs to God and is out of place in the body.
  • The soul must pass the powers above. Seven rulers stand between earth and God. Compare the soul's climb in the Poimandres with the one in the Gospel of Mary.
  • A revealer brings the teaching. It comes as a vision or a private conversation, and the one who receives it is sent to teach others.

Where they part

The maker of the world. This is the clearest difference. In the Poimandres the craftsman of the cosmos comes straight from God and does God's will:

And God-the-Mind, being male and female both, as Light and Life subsisting, brought forth another Mind to give things form, who, God as he was of Fire and Spirit, formed Seven Rulers who enclose the cosmos that the sense perceives. Men call their ruling Fate.

Poimandres, section 9

In the Secret Book of John the maker is a mistake. He is born when the divine Wisdom, Sophia, acts alone, and he does not know that anything exists above him. This is Samuel Zinner's public-domain translation:

Further, the archon who is feeble possesses three names, the first name being Yaltabaoth, the second being Saklas, and the third being Samael, and he is wicked in his pride that is inside him, because he said: ‘I am God, and there is no god other than me,’ because he is unaware of his strength, the place from which he originated.

Secret Book of John, NHC II 9 to 13

One text has a craftsman who is God's child. The other has a demiurge who is ignorant and proud, and whose seven rulers are jailers.

Christ. The Secret Book of John is a Christian book: the risen Savior appears to John, the son of Zebedee, and explains everything. The Poimandres calls the divine Word “Son of God”, but there is no Jesus in it, no cross and no church. Its teacher is Mind itself, and its sage is Hermes.

Scripture. Both know the book of Genesis and use it very differently. The Poimandres echoes it with respect. Its God says “Increase ye in increasing, and multiply in multitude” (section 18), a line the scholar C. H. Dodd traced to the Greek Genesis in The Bible and the Greeks (1935). The Secret Book of John retells Genesis against the grain, with the creator as the one who deceives.

The world and the body. Here the usual summary, that Hermetic texts love the world and Gnostic texts hate it, is a tendency and not a rule. The French scholar A.-J. Festugière sorted the Hermetic treatises into two groups for this reason: some praise the cosmos as the visible image of God, and others call it a place to escape. The Poimandres itself is hard on the body. The one who spends his love on it, the text says, “stays in Darkness wandering” (section 19). And the Gnostic texts are not all equally dark. What can be said safely is narrower: no Hermetic text makes the creator a villain, and many Gnostic texts do.

Hermetic texts in the Nag Hammadi jar

The two traditions were not only neighbours. They shared readers. Among the thirteen books found near Nag Hammadi in 1945, Codex VI holds three Hermetic works beside its other texts: the Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth, in which Hermes leads a pupil up to the highest spheres, the Prayer of Thanksgiving, and a section of the Asclepius in Coptic. After the prayer the scribe added a short note of his own, saying that he had many more writings of Hermes and had left them out. Whoever gathered those books saw no wall between Hermes and the Gnostic gospels. The full contents are on the complete list of the Nag Hammadi library.

Side by side: Poimandres and the Secret Book of John

PoimandresSecret Book of John
TraditionHermetic, not ChristianGnostic (Sethian), Christian
Who revealsPoimandres, the Mind of GodThe risen Savior, to John
The highest GodMind, who is Light and LifeThe Monad, the unseen Spirit
Who makes the worldA second Mind, brought forth by GodYaltabaoth, born of Sophia's error
The sevenRulers whose government is FateAuthorities who serve Yaltabaoth
Why humans are dividedThe divine Human fell in love with NatureThe rulers shut a spark of light inside a body they made
How one is savedBy knowing oneself, then rising through seven zonesBy waking to a call from above
JesusAbsentThe teacher of the whole book

The hymn that closes the Secret Book of John puts its own version of the call in a few words: “He who hears, let him rise up from the deep slumber” (NHC II 30 to 31). The Poimandres ends with its seeker saying nearly the same thing to a crowd. The two books agree that people are asleep. They disagree about who built the room. You can read both, complete and free: Poimandres and the Secret Book of John.

Common questions

Is Hermeticism the same as Gnosticism?

No. They are separate movements from the same world, Roman Egypt in the first centuries CE. Both teach that knowing God frees the soul. Hermetic texts speak in the name of Hermes Trismegistus and are not Christian. Most Gnostic texts are Christian and tell of a lesser god who made a flawed world.

Is the Poimandres a Gnostic text?

It is usually classed as Hermetic, not Gnostic. It shares a great deal with Gnostic writings: a divine human who falls into nature, an ascent through seven spheres, and salvation by knowledge. But its maker of the world is God's own offspring and does nothing wrong.

Which is older, Hermeticism or Gnosticism?

Neither can be shown to come first. The Hermetic treatises are usually dated between about 100 and 300 CE, and the main Gnostic systems appear in the second century. They grew up side by side and drew on the same Greek philosophy.

Were Hermetic texts found at Nag Hammadi?

Yes. Codex VI holds three: the Discourse on the Eighth and Ninth, the Prayer of Thanksgiving, and a part of the Asclepius in Coptic. Whoever owned those books read Hermes beside the Gnostic gospels.

Is it Hermeticism or Hermetism?

Both are used. Many scholars keep Hermetism for the ancient texts written in the name of Hermes, and Hermeticism for the wider tradition that grew from them in the Renaissance and after. In everyday use the two words mean the same thing.